The NYX pearl pots are super gorgeous, but they do have a ton of fall-out (to be expected). The only other vegan color they had at Ulta was a pale mint green shade (pictured, which I might go back and get). The color I am not loving is the black pearl one. It has no shimmer to it whatsoever. It looks almost matte even.... Not sure why, but I doubt I'll use that one ever since I have pressed shadows of the same color. The rest of the colors were gorgeous.
I liked the applicator for the gold eyeliner but found it odd that it "can't be used near the eyes" - not sure where else to use it. I tried it around my eyes and it BURNED, but it went away and I had no breakouts or rash the next day. Proceed with caution with that one.
The JONNY Cosmetics colors are to die for because they are SOOOO rich and creamy. I also love that the packaging specifies cruelty-free and recycling! I ordered a couple more colors from my local salon (LAVA Salon in Charleston - go to Spencer!) who carries them. They have this color called Jungle that is ridiculous awesome (I ordered it). I also think if you add a little MAC Fix+ to the shadow brush, that these will appear more foiled. I'll do a tutorial on these shades to see ;)
What are your favorite shimmery shadows? Let me know in comments!